You’ll recognize it right away, and then notice it isn’t the one you grew up with. Real peanut butter, brown sugar and a touch of honey give it a soft, chewy bite and a richer, deeper flavor. Low-key amazing.
4 oz · 2 ozContains: wheat, milk, peanut, egg
Brown sugar dough with a touch of molasses, packed with semi-sweet chunks, milk and dark chocolate chips. The one we’d never take off the menu.
4 oz · 2 ozContains: milk, soy, egg, wheat
Meet the chocolate lover’s dream! We bloom Dutch cocoa to wake up all that rich, deep chocolate goodness, then pile in semi-sweet, milk, and dark chocolate chips. Three kinds of chocolate, one seriously decadent cookie.
4 oz · 2 ozContains: milk, egg, wheat
Made with top-tier apple cider and our own cozy blend of cinnamon, allspice, clove, and ginger, rolled in spiced sugar with just a whisper of cardamom! The fall donut stand, minus the line.
4 oz · 2 ozContains: milk, egg, wheat
Signature
+$0.50 (2 oz) or +$0.75 (4 oz) in a Classic box
Our peanut butter cookie meets homemade marshmallow fluff. The lunchbox sandwich you remember, turned into a cookie.
4 oz · 2 ozContains: milk, egg, wheat, peanut
Brown butter brings the flavor, but homemade toffee steals the show! We fold buttery, golden toffee pieces into our brown butter dough along with generous chunks of milk and semi-sweet chocolate. Every bite is rich, buttery, and packed with little crunchy pockets of toffee. A little salty, a little sweet, and a whole lot of delicious.
4 oz · 2 ozContains: milk, egg, wheat
Nutty brown butter, rich brown sugar, a touch of honey, and plenty of pecans make this cookie something special. We finish it with a generous praline topping for another layer of buttery, caramelized goodness. Rich, chewy, crunchy, and just the right amount of sweet. A pecan lover's dream!
4 oz · 2 ozContains: milk, egg, wheat, pecans
Brown butter, coconut, and white chocolate are a pretty irresistible combination. We blend rich, nutty brown butter with coconut oil, then fold in shredded coconut and creamy white chocolate chips. Buttery, chewy, and perfectly sweet, with coconut in every bite. Simple ingredients, seriously good cookie.
4 oz · 2 ozContains: milk, soy, egg, wheat
Chocolate chunks, almonds and our homemade marshmallow fluff in one chewy cookie. The ice cream parlor classic, baked.
4 oz · 2 ozContains: milk, egg, wheat, almonds
All the nostalgia, none of the foil wrapper! We start with buttery vanilla dough dotted with bits of brown butter, tuck a sweet strawberry compote inside, and finish with a vanilla-strawberry glaze colored naturally with real fruit. It's sweet, buttery, a little fruity, and every bit as fun as you remember. Your childhood favorite just got a homemade makeover!
2 oz · 4 ozContains: milk, egg, wheat
We start with brown sugar dough, bring in the warmth of cinnamon and pumpkin pie spice, and load it up with creamy white chocolate chips. Every bite is soft, warmly spiced, and just sweet enough. Finished with a pretty drizzle of white chocolate for good measure. Basically, sweater weather in cookie form.
4 oz · 2 ozContains: milk, soy, egg, wheat
Premium
+$1.50 in a Classic box
A little party in every bite! Our soft, vanilla cake-style cookie is packed with colorful, dye-free sprinkles and topped with a generous scoop of homemade ermine frosting. If you've never tried ermine frosting, imagine the silky, fluffy goodness of vanilla ice cream in frosting form. It's light, creamy, and not too sweet. Birthday cake vibes with a little extra magic!
Contains: milk, egg, wheat
A graham cookie piled high with all the good stuff! We layer on homemade caramel, buttery apple crumble, and apple white chocolate, then finish with a drizzle of chocolate. Every bite brings together sweet apple, crunchy crumble, rich caramel, and chocolate. A little messy, completely over the top, and absolutely worth it!
Contains: milk, egg, wheat
A little graham, a lot of chocolate, and marshmallow everywhere. Our graham cookie has homemade marshmallow fluff and plenty of milk and semi-sweet chocolate baked right in. Then we pile on even more homemade marshmallow fluff and toast it until golden, gooey, and irresistible. No campfire, no sticky fingers, just the good stuff!
Contains: milk, soy, egg, wheat
That classic marshmallow-and-crunch combination deserves its own cookie! Rich brown butter dough with homemade marshmallow baked right inside. Another generous scoop of homemade marshmallow fluff piped on top and toasted until golden. Buttery, crispy around the edges, soft in the middle, and full of marshmallow magic. You’re going to want this one in your box!
Contains: milk, egg, wheat
Your favorite coffee order just got a cookie makeover! We bake real pumpkin purée, warm pumpkin spices, and creamy white chocolate chips into a soft, spiced cookie. Then comes the good part: a generous swirl of homemade latte buttercream. Your coffee break in a cookie!
Contains: milk, soy, egg, wheat
Hot cocoa, but make it a cookie! We start by blooming rich Dutch cocoa into a milk chocolate dough, then roll it in a cinnamon-chili sugar crust for a little warmth and a subtle kick. Inside? A decadent fudge center. On top? A generous dollop of homemade marshmallow, because hot chocolate without marshmallows just isn't the same. Rich, fudgy, a little spicy, and seriously cozy.
Contains: milk, soy, egg, wheat
We took the chocolate chip cookie and gave it a serious upgrade! Start with our classic chocolate chip cookie, add a generous layer of mini-chocolate-chip frosting, then pile on edible cookie dough. And yes, you read that right — cookie dough on a cookie, made without eggs and meant to be enjoyed exactly as it is. Because apparently, one cookie just wasn't enough
Contains: milk, soy, egg, wheat
We took the double chocolate chip cookie and gave it a serious upgrade! Start with our rich, chocolate-packed cookie, add a generous layer of mini-chocolate-chip frosting, and edible cookie dough. And yes, you read that right — cookie dough on a cookie, made without eggs and meant to be enjoyed exactly as it is!
Contains: milk, egg, wheat, soy
A little sweet and a whole lot pretty! Our buttery graham cookie gets a generous layer of homemade cheesecake filling, then a shower of strawberry crumble made with freeze-dried strawberries. The result? Bright strawberry flavor, creamy sweetness, and a little crunch in every bite. This one's as fun to look at as it is to eat. Save a spot for it in your cookie box!
Contains: milk, egg, wheat
A golden graham cookie with a delicious secret tucked inside! We fill it with our homemade salted caramel, creating a rich, buttery center that brings just the right amount of sweet and salty to every bite. It's soft, gooey, golden, and drizzled with chocolate for good measure. If caramel is your weakness, consider this your warning. You're going to want one!
Contains: milk, egg, wheat
For those days when a little chocolate just won't cut it! A Dutch cocoa cookie, packed with milk, semi-sweet, and dark chocolate chips, and finished with a thick layer of homemade Dutch chocolate buttercream icing. Deep chocolate flavor from the first bite to the last, with plenty of fudgy goodness in between. Three layers of chocolate and absolutely no reason to hold back. Make room for this one!